As soon as you upgrade, you should be able to now choose any of the premium badges as well as turn the cart and homepage locations on or off.
Step 1: Click on the '+ Add badge' button in the left menu. Then click on the any of the dropdowns other than 'Basic Badges'. If you can select any of these badges then your premium upgrade was a success.
This is what you will see if you have Premium
This is what you will see if you do not have Premium
Step 2: If you upgraded and are still not able to select premium badges, please confirm that you were actually charged for the Premium version. Once you have confirmed that, please reach out to our support team at firstname.lastname@example.org and provide the following information.
1. Description of the issue
2. Your default Shopify store URL (Example: storename.myshopify.com)
Our team will send a request for collaborator access to help you with the issue.